Riccardo 
In recent years, the landscape of filmmaking has undergone significant changes. Standalone films are increasingly giving way to expansive movie universes, with Marvel and DC leading the charge. These interconnected narratives span multiple films, creating a cohesive and immersive experience for fans. However, this shift has sparked a debate among filmmakers about the impact on traditional storytelling.
James Mangold’s Perspective
James Mangold, the acclaimed director of “Logan,” has been vocal about his concerns regarding large movie universes. He argues that the focus on connecting different films often comes at the expense of telling a compelling and emotional story. Mangold believes that movies should evoke strong feelings about the characters and their journeys, without relying on connections to other films or hidden Easter eggs.In an interview, Mangold stated, “I don’t like multi-movie universe-building. I think it’s the enemy of storytelling. The death of storytelling. It’s more interesting to people the way the Legos connect than the way the story works in front of us” 1. He emphasizes that the primary goal should be to create a unique and emotionally resonant film, rather than setting up future movies or referencing past ones.
The Marvel Universe Example
The Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) is a prime example of this trend. While the interconnected nature of Marvel movies creates an exciting experience for fans who follow the series, it can make individual films feel less unique. Directors often face the challenge of balancing standalone narratives with the overarching storyline of the universe. This can dilute the emotional impact and depth of each film, as they are frequently tasked with setting up future installments or tying into previous ones.
Standalone Films vs. Franchises
Mangold’s preference for standalone films is evident in his work on “Logan.” Unlike many other superhero movies, “Logan” does not heavily rely on the broader X-Men universe to tell its story. Instead, it focuses on the character of Logan, his struggles, and his journey, creating a powerful and emotional experience for the audience. Mangold’s approach highlights the potential for standalone films to deliver deep, character-driven narratives without the constraints of a larger universe.
The Broader Debate
The debate between large movie universes and traditional storytelling is a crucial one. On one hand, interconnected movies can create a rich and immersive world for fans. On the other hand, they can sometimes sacrifice deep, emotional storytelling for the sake of building a larger universe. Mangold’s critique underscores the importance of maintaining a balance between the two approaches.As moviegoers, we must decide what we value more: the excitement of a connected universe or the emotional depth of standalone stories. Both have their strengths, and finding a balance between the two might be the key to the future of filmmaking.
Conclusion
The rise of big movie universes has undeniably changed the way stories are told in films. While they offer a unique and immersive experience for fans, they also pose challenges for traditional storytelling. Filmmakers like James Mangold remind us of the importance of emotional resonance and character-driven narratives. As the industry continues to evolve, striking a balance between interconnected universes and standalone films will be essential for preserving the art of storytelling.
